公共政策的视角下中国协商式民主之包容性与经济增长关系研究A Research of the Relation between Inclusiveness of Chinese Deliberative Democracy and Economic Growth from a Perspective of Public Policy
周勤,黄亦然,聂卉
摘要(Abstract):
本文从公共政策的视角,以1994~2008年中国大陆23个省份跨地区数据为基础,分析中国协商式民主以党派、界别促使公共政策影响经济增长路径、机理和绩效,研究发现中国协商式民主在短期可以通过公共政策明显正向影响中国的经济增长,而随着民主进程的深化可能影响经济增长的速度,呈现"U"状况,但是从最终可以实现我们希望的两者并驾齐驱的结果,并给出了三点政策启示。
关键词(KeyWords): 协商式民主;包容性;公共政策;经济增长
基金项目(Foundation):
作者(Author): 周勤,黄亦然,聂卉
DOI: 10.13269/j.cnki.ier.2012.03.001
参考文献(References):
- [1]十四大以来重要文献选编(上)[M].北京:人民出版社,1996.
- [2]Joseph Schumpeter,1942,Capitalism,Socialism and Democracy.
- [3]Anthony Downs,1957,An Economic Theory of Democracy.
- [4]Huntinton,Samuel P.,1987,Understanding Political Development:An Analytic Study,Boston:Little Brown.
- [5]Irowy L,A Inkeles,1990,The Effects of Democracy on Economic Growth and Income Inequality:A Review,Studies inComparative International Development,25:126—157.
- [6]Adelman Irma,Cynthia Taft Morris,1967,Society,Politics and Economic Development:a Quantitative Approach,Balti-more:Johns Hopkins University Press.
- [7]Meyer,John W,Michael Hannan,et al.,1979,National Economic Development,1950—70:Social and Political FactorsIn National Development and the World System,Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
- [8]Weede Erich,1983,The Impact of Democracy on Economic Growth:Some Evidence from Cross-national Analysis(36):21—39.
- [9]Landau,Daniel,1986,“Government and Economic Growth in the LDCs:An Empirical Study for 1960—1980”,Econom-ic Development and Cultural Change,(35):35—76.
- [10]Marsh,Robert M.,1988,Sociological Explanations of Economic Growth,Studies in Comparative International Develop-ment,(23):41—77.
- [11]Feierabend Ivo K,Rosalind L Feierabend,1972,“Coerciveness and Change:Cross-national Trends”,American Behav-ioral Scientist,(15):11—28.
- [12]Dick,G.Williams,1974,“Authoritarian Versus Nonauthoritarian Approaches to Economic Development”,Journal of Po-litical Economy,(82):817—27.
- [13]Russett,Bruce M,R Joseph Monsen,1975,“Bureaucracy and Polyarchy as Predictors of Performance:A Cross-nationalExam”,Comparative Political Studies,(8):5—31.
- [14]Marsh Robert M,1979,“Does Democracy Hinder Economic Development in Latecomer Developing Nations?”,Compara-tive Social Research,(2):215—48.
- [15]Kohli,Atul,Michael Altfeld,et al.,1984,“Inequality in the Third World”,Comparative Political Studies,(17):283—318.
- [16]Sloan,John and Knet L.Tedin,1987,“The Consequences of Regime Type for Public Policy Outputs”,Comparative Po-litical Studies,(20):98—124.
- [17]Robert J Barro,1996,“Democracy and Growth”,Journal of Economic Growth,(3):1—27.
- [18]William Easterley,Can Institutuions Resolve Ethnic Conflict?World Bank Policy Research Working Paper,2482.
- [19]Roberto Rigobon,Dani Rodrik.Rule of Law,Democracy,Openness and Income Estimating the Interrelathionships,NBER WORKING PAPER SERIES,Working Paper:10750.
- [20]Iftekhar Hasan,Paul Wachtel,Mingming Zhou,2009,“Institutional Development,Financial Deepening and EconomicGrowth Evidence from China”,Journal of Banking&Finance,33:157—170.
- [21]Marta Reynal-Querol,2005,“Does Democracy Preempt Civil Wars?”,European Journal of Political Economy,(6):445—465.
- [22]Dahl,Robert,1989,Democracy and Its Critics,New Haven,CT:Yale University Press,pp.108—110.
- [23]Benhua Yang,2008,“Does Democracy Lower Growth Volatility?A Dynamic Panel Analysis”,Journal of Macroeconom-ics,(30):562—574.
- [24]周申,杨红彦.经济开放条件下劳动力市场灵活性与内资企业劳动生产率[J].国际贸易,2012(3):64—78.
- [25]Diapak K Gupta,M C Madhavan,Andrew Blee,1998,“Democray,Economic Growth and Political Instability:An Inte-grated Perspective”,Journal of Socio-Economics,(27):587—611.